DISCUSSION ON THE IDEOLOGY AND STRATEGY OF THE UNION STATE
On October 17, 2017, an extended meeting of the Presidium of the Public Chamber of the Union State was held at the President Hotel (Moscow), dedicated to the topic "On the ideology and strategy of the Union State.".

The meeting was attended by Copresident of the Russian Historical Society, Academician of the Russian Academy of Sciences Alexander Chubaryan, Deputies of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation Petr Pimashkov and Yuri Misheryakov, Executive Secretary of the Inter-factional Deputy Group of the State Duma of the Russian Federation for the Protection of Christian Values Oleg Efimov, Director of the Foundation of the Apostle Andrew the First-Called Vladimir Bushuev, Member of the Bureau of the Presidium of the World Russian People's Council, Co-president of the Union of Orthodox Women Nina Zhukova, president of the Council of the Society for the Development of Russian Historical Education "Double-Headed Eagle", Lieutenant General Leonid Reshetnikov, president of the Business Club of Women of Belarus and Russia Tatyana Glazunova, Writers Anatoly Andreev and Anatoly Pshenichny, Archpriest Vsevolod Chaplin, Head of the Belarusian Republican Confederation of Entrepreneurship Viktor Margelov, Professors Vasily Dadalko and Olga Shumakova, other prominent representatives of the expert community of Russia and Belarus.
Alexander Olshevskiy. Head of the Office of the Civic Chamber of the Union State and member of the Committee on Economic Integration and Foreign Economic Activity of the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the Russian Federation, delivered one of the keynote addresses He noted that over the 20 years of its existence, the Union State has naturally become one of the most stable and effective integration entities on the international stage. However, it must be acknowledged that while 20 years ago, at its creation, the prospect of a complete merger between Russia and Belarus, in every sense, was seriously considered, today's agenda has changed significantly. Today, the Union State is a supranational integration association of two equal and sovereign partners, which should be developed on the basis of mutual respect and mutual benefit. Moreover, the economic aspect of this integration is becoming a primary focus.
It is significant that, against this backdrop, the system of working bodies of the Union State has not undergone any transformation over the past decades and has remained in the same, initially transitional form established 20 years ago as an interim step toward the potential merger of the two countries. This transitional format significantly limited their capabilities and powers to a rather narrow corridor of short-term tasks, depriving them of any room for maneuver in strategic and long-term matters. It was precisely because of their transitional nature that, even at the initial stage, public committees supporting it and the first Union Public Chamber played such a significant role in the formation of the bilateral Union, providing the idea of integration with expert substantiation, support from opinion leaders, and its dissemination to the regions and broad sections of the population in both countries. Perhaps this, in part, explains the urgent need in Russian-Belarusian relations today to rely on the expert community and opinion leaders of both countries, who are jointly capable of formulating (or, more accurately, aligning it with objective reality) the ideology and strategy of the Union State.
It's clear to both sides that the integration phase, which has stalled at an unclear stage, should long since have been completed. The fact that reality has rendered the union of Belarus and Russia somewhat different from what was originally planned should not be shyly acknowledged publicly, and work should be done based on this. At the same time, the resulting union is by no means worse than originally envisioned, offering no fewer joint opportunities and prospects; it's simply different than it was 20 years ago—in part because the global situation has also changed significantly over these 20 years. Therefore, the longer we ignore objective reality, the more misunderstandings and barriers arise in our relations. It is absurd and unacceptable when relations between our closest and most reliable allies even reach the point of mutual trade wars, information wars, and interdepartmental conflicts—which only benefits third parties unfriendly to both our countries, while for the Union State, it leads to self-destruction or, at a minimum, the paralysis of the established integration mechanisms.
Nevertheless, the fate of the original concept of the Union State, the formation of the Constitutional Act envisaged by the treaty establishing it, and the unified Parliament are long-term and general political issues, resolved at the level of the Supreme State Council and the highest political will of both sides, and depend on a vast number of factors. Clearly, this isn't a question for tomorrow or even the day after tomorrow, so for now, there's no practical point in dwelling on what might have happened differently. Instead, it's more appropriate to consider proposals for new vectors for this process.
However, another question, one that directly concerns the expert community, is what to do with the powerful integration structure we already have. How can it be used most effectively for both countries, and what should be developed and strengthened within it? It's shameful to ignore the fact that both Belarus and Russia have their own economic and political interests, sometimes different, but in which they require the assistance or at least the understanding of their closest ally. It's unacceptable and unacceptable to fail to understand each other in the current state of our countries, to fail to show mutual consideration and respect. We all see the consequences of a superficial approach to Ukraine.
The fact that Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko, who has always been and remains one of Russia's most reliable and honest friends, has recently been given occasion to remind certain members of the Russian government of the very existence of the Union State speaks volumes. An artificial attempt to freeze relations with an ally in a form and under conditions that no longer exist is extremely dangerous. This is losing our international ties, undermining our own economic security, and severing the bonds that unite us. The resulting mass of friction and specific problems in bilateral relations, alas, cannot be resolved by holding a "Slavic Bazaar," joint ribbon cuttings and balloon launches, concerts, and mutual protocol greetings.

Based on such a preamble, compiled from the positions of the Chamber members, expressed by them from different points of view, during the meeting, one of the priorities in the work of the Civic Chamber of the Union State was defined as holding a series of hearings and combining the available expert, intellectual, scientific and other resources for joint strategic developments, the product of which will be presented to the heads of state, national departments, and our entire society.
Today's global problems with the self-identification of peoples and states, with the formulation and adjustment of unifying national ideas have directly affected the Union State. Indeed, as has been repeatedly noted at Russian-Belarusian events, even a number of the simplest questions about its essence are difficult to answer not only for ordinary citizens, but also for the current apparatus of the Union executive bodies. The key questions on which it seems useful to form a common understanding in order to preserve the established and successful development of Russian-Belarusian relations are, at a minimum:
• What is the Union State today? What are its real advantages? Where is it heading, and what would we all like to achieve with it?
• What unites us, besides geography and language? In what specific areas are our countries integrating?
• What is common sacred and absolutely valuable for both our peoples? What would we like to preserve together?
• In what areas should and can the policies of Belarus and Russia be coordinated? What effect do we want to achieve through this policy coordination?
• What common threats and risks can we and are ready to counter together? Who is our real and potential enemy, both external and internal?
• What is the standard of a person and a citizen for us? What kind of citizen and what kind of society are we trying to create together?
• How do we plan to practically use the existence of this integration structure, and what can we really achieve together better than separately?
• What is our distribution of roles and specialization within the Union State, since we are still different in many ways?
• Who are we together on the international arena and in other integration associations?
• What areas do we consider inviolable and not included in the zone of union integration, entirely attributed to the area of national sovereignty?

As Academician Alexander Chubaryan, who also heads the Association of History Institutes of the CIS Countries, rightly noted, today many countries and international associations are experiencing difficulties in defining their development vision and even their place in the world. This can be clearly observed in the example of the European Union, both as a whole and within its individual member states. Starting with the simplest: for many, contrary to natural logic and geography, it has become undesirable to identify with Eastern Europe, and the overwhelming majority of Eastern European countries, including the Baltic states, are now seeking to define themselves as "Central Europe." Amid this absurd expansion of the "center," only two countries—Belarus and Russia—remain practically Eastern European. And if we're talking about developing a unified approach to shared history—from assessments of World War II and attempts to reassess its results to events of much greater antiquity, when some can no longer divide rights to Kievan Rus', the Grand Duchy of Lithuania, or the extent of participation in World War I or the Napoleonic Wars—for genuine mutual understanding among the participants of the Union State, it's necessary to clearly formulate an ideological foundation that encompasses common ground, values, and foundations that are truly shared by Belarus and Russia. Only then can they be effectively defended, without descending into misunderstandings and excesses.
A document that has long been ripe for such a foundation and could well emerge in today's conditions is a kind of short declaration of values for the Union State. This is one of the fundamental developments that will require joint expert efforts from both sides: scientists, cultural figures, economists, historians, political scientists, journalists, leading businessmen, government, public and Orthodox Christian figures, and analysts. This is a priority for the entire Civic Chamber, including the involvement of additional expert councils and methodological bodies within its commissions. As the Chamber's experts noted, without such an ideological and value-based foundation, a constitutional act or other current joint regulatory acts of the Union State will never be formed, no matter how hard its working bodies try. Without a foundation and a clear shared understanding of what it looks like today and what we want from it, regulatory frameworks will not become truly bilateral.

Another significant issue is the formulation of strategies and policies in key areas of union relations. For example, the draft Code of Cultural Figures of the Union State, introduced by Nikolai Burlyaev at the October 5 hearings. It is being actively discussed in the regions and at various venues, supplemented by various new proposals, and is being developed by a specially created drafting group. Members of the Chamber are also conducting significant work in developing the Union State's common international relations and coordinating national security policies. Common strategic approaches in the social sphere are being developed by the Inter-Commission Group on Charitable Projects, headed by Vladimir Bushuev, Director of the Apostle Andrew the First-Called Foundation; the Commission on Family Policy, headed by Nina Zhukova, Co-Chair of the Union of Orthodox Women; and the Commission on Education, headed by Galina Klimantova.

presented proposals from the commissions on economic integration, business cooperation, environmental cooperation, and energy conservation.president of the Chamber from the Belarusian side and President of the YAROVIT Holding Andrei BiryukovThese proposals focused on the economic strategy of the Union State, which is particularly necessary in the current context. Both business and economics unanimously acknowledge that the potential of an economic union within the integration of Belarus and Russia is largely untapped and, in some respects, simply underestimated. The opportunities that our countries can harness for the common good, primarily due to their differences, are truly colossal. This is due to differences in the economic model, including the level of government regulation, the scope of social guarantees, and the territorial compactness of Belarus compared to the vastness of Russia.
Beyond the obvious opportunities for coordinated action and the Union State's participation as the single and most powerful player within the EAEU, there are longer-term prospects—primarily, in the joint development of a new economic model against the backdrop of the global digital transformation of the economy and the spread of "unmanned technologies." The Chamber's specialized commissions are also working intensively in this area, which will not only ensure a robust economic component in the Union State's evolving ideology and strategy, but also ensure that its economic component is grounded in shared values and the inherent moral and cultural foundations that distinguish the Russian and Belarusian systems from those of modern Western countries.

Following the meeting, a sequence of expert hearings was outlined for an in-depth examination of various aspects of the Union ideology and strategy, and a list of key proposals and issues in this area was determined. Summarizing the heated discussions on the main agenda item, members of the Chamber noted that the Union State is one of the main foreign policy achievements of both countries and one of our core values on the international stage today, and the leaders of the expert community possess sufficient resources to protect it from pro-Western provocateurs and negligent officials. The mutually respectful Russian-Belarusian union is strong because it is based on a natural commonality, and together we will overcome any global cataclysms.

